February 6, 2011
Families are often microcosms of the general population. Any family gathering I attend shares the same spectrum of political and religious views that any poll seeks to quantify. My family also has an unusually high number of educators in it ranging from classroom teachers …to professors…to consultants. So when someone who is not an educator brings up the topic of “what’s wrong with our schools” the “discussions” are always interesting and often heated by the passion of belief. Too often though the results are confirmation of everyone’s personal beliefs and a deepening of the divide that threatens to shatter our schools and our nation. Such was the climate of a recent family gathering.
Now I am a strong advocate of following one’s passions. Such passion is the energy that fuels my 36 years in the classroom. However when that passion stops fueling positive results and is instead used to build filters so we process only those ideas that fit our own paradigm passion becomes an accelerator for destruction rather than the a fuel for growth.
The fundamentalist who shuts out or hates the person who calls God by a different name is one example. Whether that person is the Egyptian Muslim being interviewed by Christiane Amanpour or a fundamentalist Christian protesting a burial, the message is the same. I unconditionally can not hear you because your ideas do not meet my passion filter. When this happens respect vanishes and without respect no growth can occur. Stalemate or destruction are the only options available.
The same is true lately of discussions about education. So too will be the results. The casualties will be our children. As a person who believes in the power of positive passion I have been recently contemplating and reevaluating my own personal perspectives. I have considered steps I can take to ensure that I at least do not add more accelerator to the bonfire of public discussion on the state of our schools. I know that I can only change certain things, but that even a pebble can have a widening effect.
Here are some of my thoughts as of now…what are yours?
- There are poor and excellent schools in all systems from public to private to charter to home schools.
- There is room for improvement in all systems of education.
- There are effective and ineffective educators in all these systems.
- The beauty of educating everyone through high school is also our greatest challenge.
- Unions vs school districts …we need to lessen the vs.
- If we as educators want to be considered professionals, what are our responsibilities?
- Data is needed, but is only a piece of the puzzle.
- We must stop using data bites to fuel the debate on education…whether that is a case of inappropriate instruction or an improper use of a test.
- Listen as Socrates would and question to learn, not to defend.
- Be open to acknowledging a viewpoint that differs from yours. There may be more than one road to excellence.
- If it doesn’t benefit the students it doesn’t belong in education.
- Get used to change…it is an affirmation of life.
I am not quite sure where my ruminations will end up, but I know that I do not want to have my passion for learning transformed into a fuel that will in the end destroy that about which I am passionate.
August 7, 2010
I recently spent a weekend at a camp on what will remain an unnamed lake about a 90 minute drive north of New York City. It was a beautiful setting composed of rustic cabins set on a tranquil lake. Turtles and geese skimmed the surface of the water and fireflies punctuated the night sky. However my time there was anything but tranquil. Why? Because the group I was with dared to dip our toes in the lake water. Immediately a camp employee appeared as if out of a mist and warned us that there was no swimming He further informed us that the next time he saw us enter the water the cops would be called and we would be “out of there.” Now be aware that we were not swimming we were ankle-deep at the edge of the water. The hackles of the ranger were further riled when we dared to ask why swimming was not allowed. We were brusquely told “that’s the rule” and shooed away. From that moment on my group was watched and repeatedly stopped and questioned by the “powers that be”. My favorite was when one of the rangers came down from a second story patio as I and another member of my party were taking a stroll. He hurried up to us and asked about the stainless steel cup my companion was carrying commenting that he “just wanted to make sure we weren’t carrying a beer can.” These “I just want to make sure” comments were inserted at several of the drive by inspections of our cabin as well. We nicknamed these camp rangers the camp nazis. The next day our group hiked for several hours where we discovered another more secluded lake .Here we swam and dove to our hearts content…ranger free at no detriment to the environment or ourselves. We actually got to touch and experience the nature that had been dangling out of range the day before. On the final day we went kayaking on the first lake. Once again we were informed that there is no swimming (I guess these kayaks are guaranteed not to tip over). OK so we did not dare to try any maneuvers that would lead to any suspicions of swimming. But the camp nazis were not satisfied. We were the recipients of one last chastisement as we prepared to leave. With a pointed finger wag they accused us of …illegal picnicking! Actually we were rearranging some items that had gotten wet and organizing snacks for the return drive….and had dared to taste a tortilla chip! We shook our heads and gratefully headed out of the back country.
So what does this cautionary tale have to do with education? My first thought…am I a camp nazi in my classroom? Do I enforce protocols for the sake of the protocol even when it makes no sense or I have no reason for the enforcement or implementation of a rule or a procedure. How do I respond to the uncomfortable questions of my students? Am I an authoritarian? Am I unable to explain the purpose of a rule to the students? Am I robbing my students of an opportunity to explore the wilderness of learning and therefore stifling their love of learning?
If knowledge represents the nature my group sought to relish, I fear for many students the camp we stayed in is a metaphor for too many of the schools they attend. If I expand this metaphor some who run the schools are the rangers we encountered …busily enforcing rules that served no one’s interest (except the campground’s ability to reduce law suits).
We need to remember there is no risk free learning just as any encounter with nature holds risks. Our role as teachers is not to keep kids intellectually safe…but to guide them to explore new regions and ideas in their mind’s landscape. Our role is not to enforce mindless rules, but to nourish students as they develop the skills needed to weigh evidence, consider various perspectives.
April 17, 2010
I am most blessed to be able to work with four maybe five different GEAR UP schools over the next few weekends. My research for two of the sites has led to some very interesting discoveries on the topics of effective group work and effective inquiry particularly in the way we as teachers ask questions. As usual my handouts and comments will be posted here after the workshops.
Currently I am incorporating some of these techniques into my own classroom. This has meant some revamping of how I form my groups for a jigsaw for the social history of the US from 1820 to 1865. I am eager to see how it affects student learning.
Look at this site for some info and resources on these topics http://www.fisherandfrey.com
March 7, 2010
Join me in a voicethread discussion on this topic. Here is the definition we will be using as a foundation.
“Rigor is the goal of helping students develop the capacity to understand content that is complex, ambiguous, provocative, and personally or emotionally challenging.“
Source: Teaching What Matters Most; Standards and Strategies for Raising Student Achievement by Strong, Silver and Perini, ASCD, 2001.
What do you think? How would you define rigor? Does your classroom reflect rigor?
Here is the link to the discussion. I look forward to hearing your thoughts. Voicethread Rigor Thread
If you have never visited voicethread do so! How do you see it being used in your classroom?
March 3, 2010
Board meeting last night was grim…about 52 out of about 290 staff will recieve pink slips…that is a little over 1/6…talk of eliminating our librarian…this as we open a brand new library and media center next year…ironic? …and things could get worse. If you live in Cali write/call the people in Sacramento…ask them why 60% of the cuts are in education even though it accounts for 40% of the budget…ask them if they are pink slipping 1/6 of their staff? Who else has a fact based question to ask them?
February 22, 2010
I once had the opportunity to hear Rick DuFour speak on this topic and the analogy he gave really hit home with me. He simply asked what happened when someone failed their driving test. Of course the audience responded they got to retake it…several times if necessary. He then asked, “Which one counted? Did you get an average of your scores?” Of course the response was the last test mattered;that was the score your received. I began to rethink my position on testing and revised my practice so that my focus was on mastery. I think we need to remember that when students fail it is not always just their fault. What role did I have in their not understanding? What challenges do they face at home…especially in the strained economic conditions many families face today Students who do not demonstrate mastery on my assessments (both tests and projects) are allowed to retake the test or revise their project after completing some time of support session. This could be a lunch review or study time verified by a n adult in their life.It will usually include a metcognitive reflection on why they think they did poorly. I am pleased to note that when my students take the district assessment as well as the state assessment they always score on average 10% and someitmes more above the average for my site. Therefore I think that retesting is an effective learning tool that is reflected in the “real” world. After all how many of us would have our jobs if we were never allowed the luxury of learning from our failures. As posted in an Edutopia discussion. If you have not yet checked out this site, you need to do so. Look for my colleague Heather otherwise known as tweenteacher🙂
February 21, 2010
Recently I spent a morning working with the staff at my school site. This is usually my most challenging audience. Add on to that I was given a topic from the District Office and my alloted time was almost cut in half about a week prior to the presentation! Find out what happened in my February 2010 entry under Recent Activities. Could your site use this rubric on Expectations and Rigor continuum?